Thanks Breplum, RenewDave, Jeff Handy, Diehard, voletl.
RenewDave - are AAVs failing to vent, or failing to keep water in?
It seems to me that since my space restricts me to my 3 options, I can go with #1 (AAV) and meet code, but #3 which does not meet code is probably safer (a better and more...