Vent help

[ExtraMilePlumbing]

Hi guys thanks in advance. So my journeyman doesn't know how to explain to me , why my set up for vent is bad and his is ok. I'm more then glad do to it the right way but just want to know why? What's you're opinion?
Green = wc waste
Blue= vent
My choice is the top picture using a long sweep combo and quarter bend.View attachment ImageUploadedByPlumbing Forum1457045547.200159.jpg
His is using a wye , which he wants rolled 45 up with a 45 and quarter bend.

 

[frodo]

the base of a vent always has to be washed by the fixture.

if the base is washed, then crap cant settled their and block the vent

 

[frodo]

....................

 

[ExtraMilePlumbing]

Thanks frodo , you made that so clear , the journeyman couldn't do that

 

[ExtraMilePlumbing]

Here's another job, I did before on my own , now I know I messed up there too . And they will be getting sewer smells?View attachment ImageUploadedByPlumbing Forum1457069213.761153.jpg
This is a double combo on its back serving two toilets and the vent in the back

 

[frodo]

cant do that. no sewer smell, was their a wet lav ?

you should have..

 

[ExtraMilePlumbing]

No wet lavi . , so if I would have wet vented the lavi I would have been ok?View attachment ImageUploadedByPlumbing Forum1457101998.791074.jpg

 

[frodo]

nope, not like that. like this

 

[ExtraMilePlumbing]

Cool thanks

 

[Titaniumplumber]

Where are you guys plumbing ? You both need to learn how to draw an iso correctly

 

[frodo]

what ? you dont like my sloppy drawings with a mouse ?

i got my point across, must not be that bad.

but you are correct,,,i will be sure to go to my local community college and take a class



bust a move, marvel us with your skills

 

[Titaniumplumber]

It's all good however I meant the guy drawing with the highlighter. Ha ha

 

[ExtraMilePlumbing]

I got my point across too.some people actually have lots to do in a day and find ways to save time. You probably take for ever to do anything or don't have much to do in a day

 

[Titaniumplumber]

Wow touchy touchy ok sir calm down this post is getting a little hot for some reason you can't take constructive criticism so I'm done here

 

[ExtraMilePlumbing]

I do appreciate the message, just not the delivery.

 

[frodo]

It's all good however I meant the guy drawing with the highlighter. Ha ha

Where are you guys plumbing ? You both need to learn how to draw an iso correctly

me thinks someone just peed on my foot and whispered in my ear its raining

constructive criticism, on the internet can come off like an attack.
that is why the smiley face was invented.

 

[Titaniumplumber]

Sorry I don't use emojis

 

[phishfood]

Guys, let's try and treat each other better. We all deserve respect.

 

[KULTULZ]

...if everyone lit just one little candle...

Too much testosterone here...

 

[Titaniumplumber]

Ha ha you guys would get torn to shreds on the PZ